Shared Parental Leave (SPL)

24 July 2017

Shared Parental Leave causing waves in the courts!

The Shared Parental Leave Regulations came into force in December 2014 allowing parents to share the care of the child over the 52 week leave period following the birth/adoption.  SPL also saw the end of additional paternity leave.

Almost three years in and the SPL regulations are causing waves in the courts!  The reason behind this is enhanced payments during maternity leave when compared with shared parental leave pay during SPL. The former is usually female whilst the latter is predominantly male.  When you throw all of this into the mix you end up with a recipe for sex discrimination!

So, why should a male on leave to care for his new born/adopted child receive less pay than a female doing exactly the same thing.  Well, the Tribunal in the case of Ali v Capita Customer Management Ltd [2017] ruled in favour of Mr Ali concluding that a female on maternity leave could be compared with a male on SPL; whilst the Tribunal in Hextall v Chief Constable of Leicestershire Police [2016] ruled in favour of the police force concluding that the correct comparator for a man on SPL was a woman on SPL and not a woman on maternity leave.

Both cases have been appealed so it’s a case of watch this space for now!

In October 2016, the Scottish courts saw the first case test case in relation to SPL and pay in the case of Snell v Network Rail [2016]. Mr Snell was awarded £30,000 after network rail, whom both parents worked for, refused to pay Mr Snell the same amount of pay during SPL as his wife.  The court ruled that network rail’s policy was indirectly discriminatory against males.

These are just the first few cases on SPL and suspect they will not be the last.

If you are not sure about your policy on shared parental leave and pay and you don’t want to find yourself being a respondent in a case similar to the above, please contact us to review your policies! You may also be interested in:

Paternity Rights

Adoption Rights

Maternity Rights

Meet the Qdos Experts

Hema Mistry

Solutions Delivery Team Leader

Over her 20+ years in HR, Hema draws her expert specialist knowledge from a broad range of industries including retail, consumer goods, leisure and customer service.

Kerry Bell

Senior HR & Business Partner

Kerry recently joined Qdos and has over 20 years experience in HR and Training. She graduated with a degree in Politics and has a Masters in HR Management and Staff Development – she is a full chartered member of the CIPD.

Arti Patel

HR Business Partner

Arti Patel has recently joined the Qdos HR consultancy team as a HR Business Partner. Arti has a strong background in HR and is a fully qualified CIPD member, she has worked with challenging casework and has a good understanding of how to deal with workplace matters as they arise.

Chris Burrows

HS Training Business Partner

Chris Burrows has had a varied career within Health and Safety and gained qualifications. These include; member of IOSH with technical status and also NEBOSH with instructor and assessing qualifications.

Ruth Frank

Employment Law Consultant

Although a career in employment law was furthest from Ruth's mind when she attained her Law Degree at Coventry University, she has since found her passion for all things HR!

Contact Us

Looking for Support

Qdos Contact Details

01455 852028 – General enquiries

* Please note that all calls may be recorded for training or monitoring purposes.

Email – General enquiries – Sales enquiries